Performing RNAi Experiments in Animals

Gene silencing by RNA interference is being used routinely to study gene function in cultured mammalian cells. While this approach has been extremely powerful, it does not allow a critical evaluation of how genes function within the whole organism. To address this problem, researchers are now applying RNAi in vivo. Although still in its early stages, use of RNAi in vivo already shows promise and significant advances have been made.

The Two Basic Methods Two basic methods for triggering RNAi have been adapted for use in vivo: delivery of siRNAs, and delivery of plasmid and viral vectors that express a short hairpin RNA (shRNA) that is subsequently processed into active siRNA. As with the application of RNAi in cultured cells, use of siRNAs is more prominent than use of shRNA expression vectors. For RNAi experiments in cultured cells, effective siRNAs to a particular target of interest are easier to obtain, and because they are small and only need to cross the cell membrane and not the nuclear membrane to be effective, they are easier to deliver. In contrast, shRNA expression vectors are time consuming to construct, particularly when one takes into account the time required to create and test several shRNA sequences to find an effective one. siRNAs are also easier to deliver than plasmid based shRNA expression vectors, and they do not have the associated problems with insertional mutagenesis and immunogenicity that plague retroviral (including lentiviral) and adenoviral vectors, respectively.

The success of siRNA mediated gene silencing in vivo depends on efficient delivery and retention of the siRNA in the vasculature of a specific tissue of interest, and its effective uptake by those cells. In addition, the siRNA must remain stable until it can reach its ultimate destination. Although early, there have been reports of success using both local and systemic delivery of siRNAs.

Success with Local Administration of siRNAs Perhaps the greatest success has come with local administration of siRNA to the eye. An siRNA to VEGF delivered to the subretinal space in mice has been proven to reduce eye angiogenesis [1]. In this model, there was no need to modify the siRNA, or to complex it with lipid polymer or other delivery agents, as has been necessary in some other systems. More recently, an siRNA to VEGF, developed by Acuity Pharmaceuticals and designed to be delivered via intravitreal injection, has entered phase II clinical trials as a treatment for wet age-related macular degeneration.

In rat models, modified siRNAs to the pain related cation channel P2X3 have been successfully delivered into the brains of rats via intrathecal infusion using surgically implanted pumps; the siRNAs significantly inhibited the neuropathic pain response in this model system [2]. Although not practical for many researchers, this approach demonstrates that siRNAs can be successfully delivered locally into the rodent brain, and that in vivo functional genomics studies of CNS related genes using siRNAs are possible.

There is considerable interest in delivering siRNAs into the lung in the attempts to study pulmonary as well as infectious diseases and to potentially treat influenza, SARS, and other clinically relevant pulmonary diseases caused by RNA viruses. In one promising study, an intranasal delivery system was used in primates to deliver a SARS virus specific siRNA, resulting in reduced fever, decreased viral load, and reduced alveoli damage [3]. This study demonstrates the validity of intranasal delivery of siRNAs to the lung.

Progress with Systemic siRNA Delivery The feasibility of systemic in vivo siRNA delivery in mammals was first demonstrated using hydrodynamic tail vein injections† in mice. In this procedure, unmodified siRNAs are rapidly injected into the tail vein in a large volume of aqueous solution, resulting in localization within hepatocytes [3]. Although not clinically relevant, this procedure does permit gene function and drug target validation studies within the rodent liver, until more effective delivery technologies are developed. In support of this technique, Song and colleagues found that hydrodynamic injection of a Fas siRNA resulted in silencing of Fas in mouse hepatocytes for a period of 10 days. This treatment protected hepatocytes from Fas antibody and concanavalin A stimulated apoptosis, and protected mice from fulminant hepatitis [4]. Similarly, hydrodynamic tail vein injection of a caspase 8 siRNA protected mice against acute liver failure induced by Fas antibody or expression of Fas ligand [5].

More recently, low volume, normal pressure intravenous delivery of a modified siRNA targeting apolipoprotein B in mice resulted in gene silencing in the liver and jejunum. The siRNA was conjugated with cholesterol to provide targeted delivery, and included backbone and sugar modifications to enhance serum stability [6].

Systemic delivery of siRNAs will likely be required to target most tumor types, as well as many other in vivo targets. To this end, several groups are investigating the use of lipid based and nanoparticle based siRNA delivery complexes [7-10].

The work on systemic delivery of siRNAs illustrates three obstacles that must be overcome for siRNA to be successful in vivo: selective delivery into the desired tissue, adequate protection from degradation en route to the target tissue, and protection of the siRNA from rapid excretion. Surprisingly, rapid excretion has proven to be more of a problem than in vivo stability [11]. Although chemical stabilization is readily achieved via siRNA modification, it does not appear to be necessary in most cases, as excretion appears to occur prior to degradation. Use of nanoparticles or lipid complexes currently shows more promise than chemical modification to address the pharmacokinetics and tissue distribution issues endemic to in vivo siRNA delivery.

Looking to the Future RNAi is now firmly entrenched as an invaluable tool in most drug discovery pipelines, and further advances in the technology will no doubt enhance the utility of the technique in identifying and validating potential drug targets in vivo. In addition, siRNAs themselves have huge potential as therapeutic agents. If realized, the impact on the pharmaceutical industry would be revolutionary. The most significant hurdle for the therapeutic use of siRNAs is how to provide targeted delivery. Although significant progress has been made, delivery of nucleic acids to specific organs, tissues, and cells will require additional advances, including development of possible novel conjugations and/or formulations to specifically target certain cells. †In vivo hydrodynamic delivery of nucleic acids is covered by patents and patent applications of Mirus Bio Corporation, including U.S. Patents 6,627,616, 6,379,966 and 6,897,068 and related filings worldwide. Research and commercial uses by for-profit entities require a license--please see www.mirusbio.com for contact information.